Debunking the Myths of Bad Data

October 29, 2015
How do you know how your employees really feel? Many managers look to turnover trends, productivity and anecdotal feedback to determine how happy their workers are. Unfortunately, there are some flaws in relying solely on those sources of information: Turnover trends:

Sadly, people have an extremely high tolerance for misery. I see it all the time professionally and in friends and family members – people who are so smart, complaining about their jobs and how they only stay because it’s easier than the uncertainty of something new. True, it mustn’t be so bad that they’re willing to pack up their mug and puppy Post-its, but if they aren’t engaged they aren’t doing their best work for their team, their manager or their company.


This one seems promising. How can productivity be misleading? Well, just because your numbers are good, doesn’t mean they’re as high as they can go. If your team isn’t engaged, they may be meeting the requirements of the job, but never bothering to surpass them. Productivity is relative to the individual and the environment created for that individual. If you aren’t maximizing what you can do for them, why would they?

Anecdotal feedback:

I hope this one is obvious. When was the last time you regularly pointed out the flaws in your own manager? While some people can develop and maintain that level of candor, chances are you’re telling your spouse, friends, dog or bartender far more than you’re saying directly to your manager. Most of us are self-aware enough to protect ourselves and our careers even if it means we’re lying to your face.

So what now? Using tools like engagement surveys, third-party focus groups and interviews are the best way to assess the real environment you’re creating as a manager and the environment that’s being created by your company. Truth and honesty come only when employees can see it’s important to leadership and that they are protected even when they voice unpopular opinions. Research has shown why it matters countless times: So be brave, and commit to taking a good, hard look at what’s really going on. It’s the only way to be a truly successful manager and it will lead you to reach new heights together with your team.
Sara Forner Howland

You might also like

5 Ways for HR and IC to Get Election Ready

2020 has been a wild ride and the upcoming election is sure to add fuel to the fire. So, as a communicator or human resources professional, what should you do? Check out five ways you can support your people while staying true to your values in a tumultuous time. 

Read more
Ask the DEI Expert: Building Diverse Pipelines & Equitable Systems

Many companies say they want to hire people from more diverse backgrounds, but the problem is most organizations have systems of inequity. We sat down with Dean Delpeache, founder of Strasity, to explore how we can go beyond trainings and do the real work.

Read more
Battery Levels & Mental Health in the Workplace

The effects of the global pandemic, civil unrest, and social isolation are clear and the research backs it: Employees are struggling and companies can and should do more. So how can we better support the mental wellness of our employees? We can start by checking in.

Read more