Cures for the Common Newsletter: Information Overload and Email Fatigue

December 1, 2020

Let’s start by being frank: you’re doing amazing work! We’re not here to call your beloved newsletter children ugly and we know they are anything but common. We are here to show you small tweaks that can have a big impact, showcasing just how damn brilliant you are. 

We know your pain. You put loads of work into your newsletter each week/month/quarter and have to jump through Olympic-sized hoops to herd all the cats while keeping everything on brand and consistent. And try as you might, no one seems to get the memo that – as important as ___ may seem, it doesn’t need to be included in every single issue. 

While producing the newsletter is a tremendous amount of work for you, it’s also exhausting for your audience. They have to sift through aaallll the information, looking for the few details that apply to them. Plus, they have to do the same thing for the zillions of messages floating into their inbox day in and day out. 

If this sounds familiar to you or if you can relate, you’re not alone. At Brilliant Ink, we partner with our clients to optimize their day-to-day communications – from newsletters to intranets to all-hands meetings and beyond. And by far, the most common bugger we come across with newsletters is fatigue. Fatigue on the part of the internal communicator having to chase down all of that content – and fatigue from the readers caused by information overload. 

So how can we combat fatigue? How can we make each newsletter we send out count? How can we drive up those open and click rates? By staying laser-focused on what matters. The reality is: 


Asking Employees What’s Valuable
(Get the Dirt)

We have a few different ways we like to arrive at this information. But, believe it or not, our favorite is a good old survey asking employees to rate their level of agreement with this simple statement: 


Create a list of topics you regularly (or not-so-regularly) communicate about by going through your newsletters, intranet, and any other channel or source you have. Whether it’s 10 business topics or 30, ask your people to indicate how valuable each topic is on a 5-point scale (strongly agree down to strongly disagree). It may seem like overkill but trust us; employees can very quickly work through this. 

Of course, the last thing we would do is add survey fatigue to information fatigue. Especially because it is so wonderfully easy to do something with this data to show your people that you’re listening! 

It all starts with interpreting your survey results. And, it just so happens that an over-the-counter scatterplot (yes, a scatter plot) is the perfect way to read the data you’ve collected for this question. 

STEP 1: Lay out your topics, lay out your scale, and plot out where everything falls from your survey results. 

Even though this is helpful, what if you could really make the results sing? If you apply some simple data visualization tricks, you can IMMEDIATELY make your data more actionable, usable, and easier to interpret. Plus, you can make it much more apparent to your teams and your stakeholders what employees want you to prioritize. 

STEP 2: So, replace your Likert scale with the English words that actually convey what you’re measuring. There are topics that your audience finds highly valuable, content that’s not at all valuable, and probably a few things that fall into the middle

STEP 3: For those of you ready to take this a step further, you can segment out your results by different audiences around the company and see how sentiment around some of these topics can really vary across the board. 

Giving Employees What They Want
(What They Really Really Want)

Now that employees told you what they want, it’s time to act on that data! Here are some recommendations for each category:

Highly Valuable 

Double check your newsletters and your editorial calendar. Make sure there’s a healthy amount of these topics going out in ALL of your communications – and across all of your channels – not just newsletters. In addition, find other places where you can source content on this topic to make sure you have a wealth of it on hand, always knowing when, where, and from whom the next update might be coming. 

Less Valuable

For topics that are a bit less valuable,  limit the frequency. It’s not that these topics don’t matter, they just aren’t as high a priority or pressing for your people. So, respect their inbox (and their attention span): rather than pushing the communications out to people, find an alternate channel to house this information and make sure people can find it when they need it. 

Gray Area 

And, of course, the messy middle. There are topics that some people love, some people just don’t care, and when we average out those survey results, they wind up here. 

At one time or another, the entire company might care about and want to hear everything about a particular topic, but preferences can shift over time or vary by region, function, or tenure. 

An example of this is with COVID communications. At the start of the pandemic, all employees craved information all the time. As return-to-office policies segmented by function, so did the need for specific information. And now, with lock-down orders so wildly different across the world, different people have profoundly different needs.

For gray-area topics like this, we recommend targeted sends, and letting people opt in or out in the future. You can also consider complementary channels – like a COVID resource center on your intranet.

This also illustrates why it’s super important to do surveys and pulse checks regularly – preferences and what’s valuable to people change over time. 



All in all, your newsletter shouldn’t be the only way employees interact with important information. From the most valuable topic areas to the least valuable, it’s important to use supplementary, complementary, or alternate channels. This makes valuable information accessible to folks at any given time, and less valuable items are still accessible even if they aren’t featured in the newsletter. 

So, in short, stay super current around what’s truly valuable, and keep your editorial calendar and channel strategy nimble to provide that valuable content where, when, and how it makes the most sense.

For more bite-sized brilliance, subscribe to our monthly newsletter, the Inkwell! Be sure to keep up with us and follow us on LinkedIn and Twitter too.

Jackie Berg

You might also like

How To Refresh Company Core Values

Your core values tell employees and customers who you are. Here are the steps to refresh your core values.

Read more
7 AI Tools For Internal Communicators

With AI at our fingertips, we’re working smarter and faster. Learn how artificial intelligence (AI) can supercharge your IC toolkit and transform the way you work.

Read more
4 Common Problems With Your Employee Surveys

If your survey is flawed, your data is flawed. We're showing you 4 key engagement survey mistakes and how to fix them. Learn how to launch winning employee surveys.

Read more